Premises Liability
McAllen Apartment Complex Slip and Fall Claims: When the Property Manager Owes You
A fall on a cracked breezeway, a dark stairwell or an unmarked pothole at a McAllen apartment complex isn't automatically 'just an accident.' Here's how Texas law treats these falls and what evidence actually wins the claim.
Quick answer
If you fell in a common area of a McAllen apartment complex — a stairwell, breezeway, parking lot or pool deck — the property management company or landlord may be liable under Texas premises liability law, but only if they created the hazard, knew about it, or should have discovered it through reasonable inspection and failed to fix it. Maintenance requests, repair tickets and prior resident complaints are usually the strongest proof of that notice. The Law Office of Chris Sanchez is headquartered at 317 W. Nolana Avenue in McAllen and evaluates these claims free of charge.
McAllen's rental communities carry the same duty as any store
McAllen has grown fast, and so has its stock of apartment and rental communities — from the older complexes off Ware Road and 23rd Street to newer builds near Nolana. Whatever the age of the property, Texas law puts the same basic duty on whoever controls the common areas: keep stairwells, breezeways, parking lots, pool decks and mailbox areas reasonably safe for residents and guests. A fall there is treated the same way a fall in a store aisle is treated — as a premises liability claim, not just bad luck.
Where these falls actually happen
- Cracked or crumbling exterior stairs and loose handrails on a two-story unit.
- A breezeway or covered walkway left dark for weeks after a light burns out.
- Potholes, sunken drains and unmarked speed bumps in the parking lot.
- A pool deck or gate left slick or in disrepair around the shared pool.
- Standing water or a persistent leak in a laundry room or mailbox breezeway.
Proving the property manager had notice
Apartment falls often come with better paper evidence than a store fall, because residents leave a trail. A maintenance request submitted through the office, a repair ticket, a text or email to the property manager about a broken step or a dead light, or complaints other tenants made about the same hazard are all direct proof the owner knew about the danger and didn't fix it. Even without a prior complaint, we can show the hazard existed long enough that a reasonable inspection — the kind every complex is supposed to run — should have caught it.
Comparative fault and the filing deadline
Texas comparative fault applies here the same as any other fall claim: you can still recover as long as you're found 50% or less responsible, with your award reduced by your share. Expect the complex's insurer to argue you knew about the hazard and used the stairs or walkway anyway, so how the facts are documented matters. The deadline to sue is generally two years from the date of the fall, but the maintenance and repair records that prove your case get harder to obtain the longer you wait.
What to do after a fall at your McAllen complex
Report the hazard to the leasing office in writing and keep a copy or the maintenance ticket number, photograph the broken stair, dark breezeway or pothole and your injuries before anything gets repaired, gather any prior maintenance requests you or neighbors already submitted, get names from anyone who saw the fall or the hazard, and see a doctor the same day — McAllen's South Texas Health System and Rio Grande Regional Hospital both treat fall injuries daily. Then call us before you give any statement to the complex's insurance company. Our McAllen office at 317 W. Nolana Avenue answers 24/7, the consultation is free, and you pay nothing unless we win.
Frequently asked questions
Is my apartment complex responsible if I fell on a broken stair in McAllen?
Possibly. The property manager or owner must keep common areas like stairwells and breezeways reasonably safe and address known hazards. You'll need to show they created the hazard, knew about it, or should have found it through a reasonable inspection — maintenance requests and prior complaints are often the key proof.
What if I already submitted a maintenance request for the hazard before I fell?
That can significantly strengthen your case. A maintenance request the property manager received and ignored is direct evidence of notice, which is exactly what Texas premises liability law requires you to prove.
Does it matter if I'm a tenant versus just a visiting guest?
Not much for common areas. Both tenants and their guests are generally owed reasonable care in shared spaces like stairwells, parking lots and pool areas, since the property manager controls and maintains those areas regardless of who is using them.
Injured? Let's talk today.
Free case review. No fee unless we win.